The Registry is organized around information most likely to be sought on early Bahá'ís. The paper discusses the nature of sources consulted and a number of unique methodological problems.
Finally, the paper presents some initial findings of the Registry and discusses the relevance of the Registry for Bahá'í scholarship and historical writing.
The growing interest in Canadian Bahá'í scholarship since the establishment of the Association for Bahá'í Studies in 1975 has not been matched with the development of empirical and historical materials on the early Canadian Bahá'í Community. We conceive the years between 1893, when the Bahá'í Faith was introduced into Canada, and 1944 which marked the first Centenary of the Faith, as constituting the "early" years of the Canadian Bahá'í Community.
The lack of such materials has become particularly acute when the author, as Social Science Editor of A Short Encyclopedia of the Bahá'í Faith, tried to compile a series of about 35 articles on Canadian Bahá'í history. While the institutional aspects of this history has been somewhat documented already, the human hand of Bahá'í Canadian history remains known only to the few remaining individuals who had played a part in that history. Even for these individuals, however, there are many lapses of memory and detailed knowledge of their own company.
As Social Science Editor of the Encyclopedia I saw the absolute need to compile a Registry of these early believers which scholars and biographers could profitably explore with the knowledge that only the best possible sources were used to collect the information for the Registry. The project got underway in October 1986 and is expected to be completed during the Summer of 1987.
While I strove to include as much information of each individual as possible, I realized that the following components should constitute the minimum amount of information :
1. Names (first, maiden, last);More recently, I have started to collect occupational data on the early believers.
2. Titles (Dr., Miss, etc.);
3. Place and date of declaration of his or her Faith, or enrollment in the Bahá'í community;
4. Earliest and last known date in Canada (which may or may not coincide with date of declaration or of death);
5. Name of foremost community associated with that individual;
6. Annotations provided mainly by interviews with early believers;
7. A listing of sources consulted for each of the above items of information to guide researchers and biographers.
The Registry is notable for the wide range of sources consulted, many hitherto unknown or relatively unexplored. These include archival materials, unpublished documents, published accounts, and oral histories.
The Bahá'í National Archives of the United States in Wilmette, and those of Canada in Thornhill have yielded approximately 10,000 pages of primary materials. The most important of these include the Corinne True Papers, the Alfred E. Lunt Collection, the Windust Papers, and scores of regional histories written before 1944. Mr. Roger Dahl who also has an interest in the development of a Registry, has provided a good measure of assistance in the project.
While the archival materials are found in a few restricted areas, unpublished documents come from a great variety of sources, both institutional and individual. In some instances, early believers have been asked to present talks at Bahá'í Summer Schools and the like; we are fortunate that some have taken the effort of putting their talk to paper. With the renewed interest in Bahá'í scholarship, Canada, and the United States in particular, has seen the rise of local historians who possess at least a great deal of enthusiasm, often a rare ability to feret out improbable facts, and only occasionally an inability to understand the use of documented facts. All this will develeop in good time.
Many Bahá'ís are most familiar with published accounts. The Registry is consulting approximately 300 titles for all references to early Canadian Bahá'ís. This category includes biographies, published letters from Shoghi Effendi, Guardian of the Bahá'í Faith, and certainly Bahá'í journals: Bahá'í News, Bahá'í Canada (and its predecessor, Canadian Bahá'í News), Star of the West, Bahá'í Magazine, to list some of the more important ones.
Oral histories constitute the fourth source of information. The author has already begun a process of seeking out early believers, to secure not only oral histories, but also to direct specific questions related to a tentative Registry. While only a very few were able to provide a great deal of fresh information, virtually all of these believers provided some new data which, together with other such believers, will constitute a fairly complete Registry. When the Registry achieves a niveau of accuracy and reliability, the revised list will once again be sent to all of these believers for additional comments.
Methodological problems in developing the Registry center around two chief areas: (1) individual biography, and (2) the varying conditions of the early Canadian Bahá'í Community.
Every historian has encountered the problem of the traditional position of women. The search for the identity of Mrs. John Thomas is universal. Early accounts, as was customary in those days, would be satisfied with no more detailed description of Mrs. Thomas. Many of the early Bahá'í accounts reflect this style of biographical referencing. A remarried woman may, in fact, prop up three times in such accounts. First, as a trammeled single woman, then as a blushing bride of a first husband, finally as a deadpan wife of a second husband after the first husband's demise. Many of those who were called in by the author to help with the Registry were asked to identify women.
The second, important, problem concerns the nature of early Bahá'í communities in Canada (as elsewhere). It revolves around the question of "who is a Bahá'í?" Often, sympathetic friends of the Bahá'í Faith took part in almost as many Bahá'í functions as Bahá'ís themselves, receiving due credit in Bahá'í publications. In addition, the process of declaring oneself a Bahá'í was not only less formal than today, but the leadtime between "declaration" and "enrollment in the Bahá'í community" was also considerably longer. Some believers simply considered themselves a believer and criteria were quite loose. Other never felt the need to enroll in the Bahá'í community, although they certainly had declared.
Then, as so often happens, the most active members of the community are more "newsworthy" than the inactive ones. What possible route can we employ to uncover the latter ones? Oral interviews have proven to be one of the best ways.
Almost from the very beginning of the project, we were forced to recognize that much of the accepted knowledge of the early Canadian Bahá'ís had to be revised. First, there were a great deal more believers than official accounts indicated. A good example is the information which appears in a 1987 publication of the National Spiritual Assembly, which herebelow is compared to the numbers according to the Registry:
Table 1
A Comparison of the Number of Early
Believers in Canada
Publication Registry Difference
1893
1902
1910
1920
1930
1935
1945
The proportion of the 333 names in the Registry for 1893 and 1944 indicate the following proportion of men and women (see Table 2)
Table 2
Percentage of men and women in
the Registry and in the contemporary Bahá'í community
Men Women
Registry
Bahá'í Community
(1987)
We were also able to give a profile of the civil status of many early
believers, which is found in Table 3.
Table 3
Percentage of believers in various
Civil Status categories
Men Women
Married
Single
Unable to determine
We also determined the residence of the early believers. While it is true that some have managed to live in different communities, they have often indicated the place where they declared their belief as the "home" community. Others did not identify themselves as such and we have therefore, for statistical purposes only, divided them across their respective communities. Table 4 and 5 indicate residence by community and by province respectively, compared to current statistics.
Table 4
Percentage Distribution of Early Believers
by Major "Home" Community
Registry Bahá'í Community (1987)
Greater Montreal
Vancouver
Saint John, N.B.
Toronto
Hamilton
All other
Total % 100 % 100 %
Table 5
Percentage Distribution of Early Believers
by Major Provinces
Registry Bahá'í Community (1987)
Québec
Ontario
B.C.
New Brunswick
Manitoba
Saskatchewan
Alberta
Nova Scotia
Newfoundland
Prince Edward Island
Total % 100 % 100 %
It is too early to clearly delineate implications of the Registry in the study of the Canadian Bahá'í Community. However, the following few issues come to our mind. First, various ethnic, language, and regional groups in Canada may derive some benefit from exploring the Registry. How well is it known that that the first Black Canadian Bahá'í was Eliot of Montreal (variously spelled as "Elliott")? Does French Canada Bahá'í History begin with the declaration of ........? whose main contribution was to the Australian Bahá'í Community in the form of a permanent summer school? How well is it known that Bahá'ís could be found in Canada's peripheral areas, such as New Brunswick?
The practical importance of the Registry, however, has already been clearly evidenced by the use to which it has been put by the still-living early believers. Not infrequently, the Registry has allowed these believers to remember and reflect more accurately on the life and works which they have built up for us with their erstwhile soulmates. In that sense, the author has more than once hoped that such believers will be encouraged to either start writing their biographies, or to complete them as quickly as possible, in time for the first Centenary of the Faith in Canada in 1993.